All aspects of trials should be public

By Staff
Aug. 8, 2001
The defendant in a local murder case, extradited from Louisiana last week to the Lauderdale County jail, was allowed to enter a plea Monday in the privacy of the circuit judge's chambers as supporters, friends and family members waited in the courtroom for the hearing to begin.
Circuit Judge Larry Roberts said it is not uncommon to arraign defendants in chambers.
The problem here is that, unlike most cases, there were members of the public present in the courtroom who wanted to witness the proceeding. Three people came to support Peggy Sloan Starns, indicted for murder in the 1984 death of Angela Schnoor.
The victim's parents, now divorced, were present in the courtroom. Her sister was there, as was her mom's fianc. The special assistant attorney general who led the re-investigation of Angela Schnoor's death was present, having presumably driven from Jackson to witness the arraignment.
The judge's chambers are not accessible to the general public, and it is not a good idea to keep private a part of the judicial process that citizens have a right to see especially if they're in the courtroom waiting to see it.
Why this particular defendant was accorded such treatment has not been adequately explained. We can think of no legitimate reason why her desire for privacy should outweigh the constitutional right of the public to view the proceeding. We believe Judge Larry Roberts owes the public a better explanation.

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Mousey Brown

News

Russellville First Baptist Church receives historical marker

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Meeting a higher standard – Russellville High School JROTC

News

RCS BOE announces new superintendent  

News

Miss Dream Girl Pageant names winners

Franklin County

First Metro Bank hosts FAME Girls’ Ranch donation drive

News

PCHS holds annual Shelby Grissom Memorial Fashion Show

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: VFW Post 5184 – ‘No One Does More For Veterans’

Features

Supporting students’ futures

Features

Red Bay Garden Club discusses amaryllis planting

Franklin County

UA announces local students for fall 2023 President’s, Dean’s, graduation lists

News

School news

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Troy Oliver

Franklin County

Appropriations bill passes, allots more than $3 million for new Russellville library/multipurpose center 

Franklin County

Franklin County Cattlemen’s Association names Cattleman of the Year 

Franklin County

Franklin County votes: Unofficial March 5 primary election results 

Franklin County

Funding for new Russellville library, multipurpose community center expected this week

Features

Faces of Franklin County: BTCPA

News

GFWC Russellville Book Lovers Club sponsors downtown art crawl

Franklin County

PROGRESS 2024: Veteran Spotlight – Cody Bragwell

Franklin County

42nd annual Miss RHS pageant names winners 

News

Miss RHS pageant takes place Friday

Franklin County

Political announcement: David Hester speaks about run for reelection as county commissioner

Franklin County

BTCPA auditions for final production of season take place March 3-4 

x